A PSA to authors: I’ve had PAID betas admit before that they have bad attention spans, usually split their time 50/50 while reading client’s book, or overall just don’t give their full attention because they actually don’t like reading or read much. They’re basically scrolling TikTok while working on your book. Please be very cautious about who you hire. Vet, vet, vet!!! Make sure they have read your genre as well. I had someone say they didn’t even know space opera was a genre but wanted to take on my book. Do not hire these type of readers. You’re just going to get bad feedback you don’t deserve.

Now, not every paid reader is like this. Kayinat isn’t, which is why I hired her again. I knew I had to write her another review because she answered questions I told her would become important later in my series. I never expected her to answer them now, but she did anyway, and I was genuinely shocked. Her answers were incredibly detailed, too.

I also appreciated one of her inline comments on a casual essay I sent her, where she mentioned that she wouldn’t take on a book if she wasn’t part of the target audience. That meant a lot to me because I’ve worked with far too many beta readers who accept every project just to make money, then return unhelpful feedback. Most of them try to mask the fact they don’t like reading or they don’t have much to say about your book because they weren’t paying attention by writing a bunch of filler on a report. Kayinat doesn’t do this, THANK GOODNESS. Everything she says is helpful. All of her notes talk about a scene or the overall book instead of abstract comments like advice from Reddit.

Kayinat understands that I’m a reader too. She doesn’t spend time telling me what “other readers” want because she respects that I have my own taste. She understands her role as a beta reader and goes even further by considering who she’s working with and how certain feedback can harm a book. She recognizes that reading is subjective and doesn’t waste page space lecturing me about “the market.”

She gave me over five hundred inline comments documenting her experience as a reader. A comment like, “Now I’m mad at him!” will always be more valuable to me than someone grading my book with a template and rubric. Kayinat reads extremely carefully without needing to be told to. That level of attention comes naturally to her, and that’s how I know she’s a genuine reader.

I also got lucky that Kayinat is part of my target audience and shares similar taste, but she’s still extremely honest. If she doesn’t like something, she says so and explains why. What I value most is that she responds to what I actually wrote, not to a version of my book she invented in her head.

What I find interesting is that the people who tried hardest to impress me with a superiority complex often gave the most surface-level notes. Kayinat didn’t. It doesn’t impress me when someone spends all their time trying to sound smarter than the material while missing all the subtext. Kayinat caught it all and gave me twenty pages of notes rooted in her genuine reader experience. THAT impressed me a lot. All she had to do was be herself and read so carefully. I never worry when her emails are in my inbox. I feel excited because I know my book is going to get better just by working with her.

Careful reading will always be the most helpful kind of feedback to me, and honestly, it’s the reason I still believe paid beta readers can be worthwhile. Kayinat gave me that hope back.

​